Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Philip Sevilla's avatar

Working as an independent Catholic journalist in the 1990s in the San Francisco Bay Area, I would attend meetings at progressive parishes on controversial subjects like women's ordination and homosexuality. Typically the agenda would not be about informing attendees about Church teachings on priestly ordination clarified by Pope John Paul II in Ordinatio Sacerdotalis (1994) or Church teachings on homosexuality and sexual ethics such as Persona Humana (1975). Attendees would break up into small groups, given a topic, and a leader assigned to report to the assembly the majority opinion of the group. CLASSIC GROUP THINK tactic. Collective psychological manipulation. Rather the organizers' purpose would be to identify allies and organize agitators and dissenters within the parish community; develop and groom new change agents. In my opinion, the synod consistory's design developed by Francis' confederates, adopted by Pope Leo, is organized to muzzle, suppress opinions of conservative, traditionalist minded prelates. It is insulting to the members of the college of cardinals to isolate them, to repress their full and free opinions before the Pope, the full assembly and members of the Catholic Press. A SYNOD's purpose is consultative. The Pope consults with and gather opinions on serious subjects from eminent members of the hierarchy, the college of cardinals who should be free to discuss and give their full opinions to the Pope and members of the assembly during the consistory.

Marge Hansen's avatar

Beyond any speculation, I hope everyone is praying for the cardinals and the Holy Father, that true enlightenment prevails, tempered with compassion for the people of God.

15 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?